Voting on Ideas like in Ubuntu Brainstorm project

[JDW]

I did see this http://sourceforge.net/apps/ideatorrent/wz2100-vault/ so it looks like that is in the plans.
It pays to be nosey when devs post links.

Does it mean it's ready? or still in planning?

[Crymson]

I did see this http://sourceforge.net/apps/ideatorrent/wz2100-vault/ so it looks like that is in the plans.
It pays to be nosey when devs post links.

Does it mean it's ready? or still in planning?

I guess you can try it?
AFAIK, when he posted that link, he said he'll be back in a few weeks.

[Christheturtle]

Any new feature/tool that is ready for the public use will be announced as seen fit when and if it seems appropriate. Considering that it's not yet been announced, it's not certain if it will be used after testing.

[Zarel]

Buginator proposed IdeaTorrent on the ML, but it didn't go anywhere.

This was the only reply:

buginator wrote:
> Since we have a ton of feature requests in trac, I thought it might be
> nice to start up a IdeaTorrent on our SF site.
>
> "IdeaTorrent is what can be defined as an "open innovation software":
> it lets people submit their ideas, brainstorm them, and vote on them."
We don't need more ideas, we need more implementers! Just take a look at all the
proposal pages in the trac-wiki.

> Thoughts?
I dislike all this information scattering and if you ask the community they'll
always be for it :/ (It's like a present for them )

On the other hand: It's impossible for me to keep track of _all_ the stuff we
already have (IRC, ML, forums, tickets, wiki, guide, SVN), so it would just add
one more item to the list

[Buginator]

Buginator proposed IdeaTorrent on the ML, but it didn't go anywhere.

This was the only reply:

buginator wrote:
> Since we have a ton of feature requests in trac, I thought it might be
> nice to start up a IdeaTorrent on our SF site.
>
> "IdeaTorrent is what can be defined as an "open innovation software":
> it lets people submit their ideas, brainstorm them, and vote on them."
We don't need more ideas, we need more implementers! Just take a look at all the
proposal pages in the trac-wiki.

> Thoughts?
I dislike all this information scattering and if you ask the community they'll
always be for it :/ (It's like a present for them )

On the other hand: It's impossible for me to keep track of _all_ the stuff we
already have (IRC, ML, forums, tickets, wiki, guide, SVN), so it would just add
one more item to the list

I have to agree with Kreuvf's points Zarel - the only point of revamping a 'new ideas' section is saying "we've got crap to do but not doing it!"

[Crymson]

I have to agree with Kreuvf's points Zarel - the only point of revamping a 'new ideas' section is saying "we've got sh*t to do but not doing it!"

So you guys think this is dead before it started?

Have you guys read https://launchpad.net/ideatorrent ?
It can be set up the same way.

[Buginator]

Buginator proposed IdeaTorrent on the ML, but it didn't go anywhere.

This was the only reply:

buginator wrote:
> Since we have a ton of feature requests in trac, I thought it might be
> nice to start up a IdeaTorrent on our SF site.
>
> "IdeaTorrent is what can be defined as an "open innovation software":
> it lets people submit their ideas, brainstorm them, and vote on them."
We don't need more ideas, we need more implementers! Just take a look at all the
proposal pages in the trac-wiki.

> Thoughts?
I dislike all this information scattering and if you ask the community they'll
always be for it :/ (It's like a present for them )

On the other hand: It's impossible for me to keep track of _all_ the stuff we
already have (IRC, ML, forums, tickets, wiki, guide, SVN), so it would just add
one more item to the list

I have to agree with Kreuvf's points Zarel - the only point of revamping a 'new ideas' section is saying "we've got crap to do but not doing it!"

With the idea torrent, you can vote up / down stuff, so people don't have to keep posting the same ideas over and over and over ...

That is only one of the reasons though.

[Zarel]

Personally, I still think IdeaTorrent is a good idea.

[JDW]

Oh, this isn't settled yet?

[lav_coyote25]

Oh, this isn't settled yet?

not yet. is a good idea... thing is to figure out who is going to bring it to the front and just GD doit!!!!!

[Buginator]

working on it... if people have free time ...

[cybersphinx]

I've enabled it now. Let's see what happens.

https://sourceforge.net/apps/ideatorrent/warzone2100/ - you need some sort of extra account for it, but not necessarily a special Sourceforge account. It also accepts any OpenID account, when you need to log in, it shows you what accounts you can use there.

[lav_coyote25]

ok, did so.