Page 1 of 1

Generic tank icon

Posted: 18 Mar 2011, 20:30
by Cyp
In the in-game multiplayer alliances menu, instead of magically showing the latest tank a player built, it probably makes more sense to show the latest visible tank a player built.

If no tanks from that player are visible, what should it show instead? Someone can probably come up with something better than
image_generic_tank.png
image_generic_tank.png (391 Bytes) Viewed 5770 times
and
image_generic_tank_tc.png
image_generic_tank_tc.png (249 Bytes) Viewed 5770 times
. Answers preferably in image form.
img2.jpg

Re: Generic tank icon

Posted: 18 Mar 2011, 22:09
by Wolftrak
My opinion is that instead of the 3d Model, we should place something more meaningful.A tank if the player has mostly tanks,the same with borgs and aircrafts.Also, a rank would not be such a bad idea.

Re: Generic tank icon

Posted: 19 Mar 2011, 11:13
by Terminator
Wolftrak wrote:A tank if the player has mostly tanks,the same with borgs and aircrafts.
the whole idea was to make a fair play, so mosly used units isn't that warzone needs. Last visible unit its ok.
Wolftrak wrote:Also, a rank would not be such a bad idea.
Support. I think it would be even better than last visible unit, just show ranks & that all. :wink:

Re: Generic tank icon

Posted: 19 Mar 2011, 11:27
by NoQ
Completely removing this "spoiler" will greatly affect the game; people will have to send "scout SCVs" to find out what the opponent is doing (which is a lot of extra micro), and it will still be pretty hard to find out if the opponent is clever enough to hide his latest developments in the middle, protecting them with outdated defenses. Not sure if it's bad, but it's worth discussing.

Re: Generic tank icon

Posted: 19 Mar 2011, 11:33
by GiGaBaNE
personally i think its a terrible spoiler, if a player is runing recon properly then they can see what is coming, if not then thats their own fault.

I think this icon should be reserved for builder units only to let you know that that player has a builder of some kind.
it would help with those games where we have to trawl the map looking for the last items to kill before win can be claimed.

Re: Generic tank icon

Posted: 19 Mar 2011, 11:47
by NoQ
GiGaBaNE wrote:personally i think its a terrible spoiler
It is. But removing it will make us wake up in a very different world. We're running into another realism vs. playability/game_ideology issue here.
GiGaBaNE wrote:if a player is runing recon properly then they can see what is coming, if not then thats their own fault.
I don't think so. On a usual map, it's rather easy to hide your plans unless at least VTOLs are available.

Re: Generic tank icon

Posted: 19 Mar 2011, 12:09
by GiGaBaNE
im sure there are plenty of players that dont take advantage of that screen, i only go there to trasfer money to allies.

it removes the ability to create tech that you wish to be a secret.

no insult intended to those that use it, but as far as im concerned it is a cheat allowing you intel you havnt earned.

i would vote yes to it being completly removed, failing that it would be handy to neuter it so that it only shows if a player still has a builder lying around.

Re: Generic tank icon

Posted: 21 Mar 2011, 15:01
by effigy
I'll wager that the people that don't use this screen in MP for recon are the people that get owned frequently.

Re: Generic tank icon

Posted: 21 Mar 2011, 16:46
by Iluvalar
DrawOnTopOfEachOther("select distinct units limit 3 ordered by ((howMuchISaw-HowMuchIKilled)*TemplateCost) );

the template cost is there because i believe that 3 python on track is more relevant then 4 machine gunners.